|
Traditionally board games have never translated that well to computers.
Given the choice between running amok with Metroid
Prime: Hunters and spending all day taking enemy pawns en passant,
most normal gamers would lean heavily towards the former. That said,
you probably didn't buy your DS to play normal games, did you? Enter
the 4-in-1 "fun pack" from Atari then, creatively entitled Monopoly/Boggle/Yahtzee/Battleship;
four traditional board games translated onto the digital screen
(or in this case, screens). But have Atari made the leap from board
to computer a smooth one?
There
is simply no such thing as a person who's never played Battleship,
so it's a good place to start. A simple game, Battleship has had
countless conversions to computer. The difference here is that DS
has allowed Atari to create a touch-based version of the game. Setting
up your fleet is a simple drag and drop experience and firing is
achieved by a double tap on the relevant quadrant, or the option
to aim via the d-pad. The game is simple, straightforward and, well,
a bit dull. The huge firing area and small fleet, combined with
a lack of any real strategy doesn't really make for exhilarating
play. Battleship offers a number of different ship styles (like
Viking, pirate or space-age) with cute enough graphics, but is otherwise
every bit as dull as it sounds. It's good for a little diversion
but thank Odin there're three other titles available on the same
cartridge.
Yahtzee
is, well… Yahtzee, a game that uses six dice and a simple scoring
sheet. It translates surprisingly well to the DS, thanks to the
touch screen. Selecting dice to keep and areas in which to score
is very easy and the interface is uncluttered. Simple and intuitive,
Yahtzee has the exact same downfall as Battleship; it might keep
you busy for a few minutes but unless you're a big fan of the board
game, don't expect to be drooling at the mouth for more Yahtzee
DS.
Then
there were two. Boggle is the third offering, a game that challenges
the player to find as many words in a grid as possible in three
minutes. Boggle is Boggle - there's nothing here that breaks the
rules or discovers new frontiers, but I have a serious addiction
to this version. Again, the DS touch screen makes it so very simple
to play; just tap out the letters of each word with a double tap
on the last letter, or touch and drag the stylus over the necessary
letters and release when done. I have to admit I've always enjoyed
Boggle and likewise enjoy this version, but if you're not interested
in word games, you'll not find anything intriguing here. Battleship
for Battleship fans, Yahtzee for Yahtzee fans, and yes, Boggle for
Boggle fans.
Which
leaves Monopoly, the most ambitious project on the cart. A much
more complex game, unlike the others Atari had a lot of scope to
stuff this one up. Luckily they didn't… much. The cute graphics
and easy-to-use trading system are a very nice touch over other
digital versions of monopoly, but there are just too many basic
problems with the way the game is implemented. This is a shame too,
because the touch screen capabilities of the DS could have made
for a brilliant conversion.
Yet
I cannot forgive these problems. For example, even on the lowest
difficulty, I couldn't get any computer players to trade over the
third property in a set for cash. Furthermore, when I did have a
set, I couldn't buy any houses because every time I tried the computer
opened up bidding at the highest price for the house - I'm pretty
sure that's not in the rules. Atari really puts the boot in by setting
up dozens of neat gameplay options but then forcing you to use the
American-named version of the board. Just a few more bytes of code
and at the least I could use the familiar English street names.
It's like dangling food in front of a starving man before snatching
it away. Such promise and potential, and Atari never realises it.
It gives me the feeling that Atari was in a bit of a rush to get
to the deadline on this one.
The
final straw is the multiplayer modes. Like many other games, you
can download this one into other DS systems through the wireless
connection and play using only one cart. I wouldn't recommend it
though, since along with no sound, you'll find that you have to
download each game every single time you play. Just the option to
play again without having to restart is all we're asking for Atari
- what have we done to offend you?! Now we spend more time downloading
Boggle than playing it.
All
in all, if you can get it cheap or steal it from a kid in a lower
grade, then Monopoly/Boggle/Yahtzee/Battleship is a reasonable diversion
for a few minutes, especially if you have a particular love for
one or more of those games. For all but Monopoly, the translation
to digital has been handled very well, and the speed and simplicity
of play allows for pretty good replay value. Unfortunately, these
were never the most exciting games and with a host of absorbing,
entertaining and unique games available on the DS, this is definitely
for hardcore fans only.
Reviewed by Steven Rosenthal for AceGamez (All Rights Reserved).
|